Skip to content

Can My Insurance Be Effected by Ford’s F-150 Crash Results?

🎙️ Enjoy our PODCAST on this topic

* podcast transcript

EVA
Ever feel like car shopping is just a big puzzle? Safety features, insurance, it all gets jumbled together.

MAX
Yeah, finding that balance is tricky, especially with how fast car tech changes.

EVA
Totally. And get this, there’s a new crash test making things even more interesting. It’s called the Small Overlap Front Crash Test, and today we’re diving deep into how it might change what we pay for car insurance. We’re looking at an article about the Ford F-150, specifically how it did on this new test, and the results. Pretty surprising, actually.

MAX
So the thing about this small overlap test is it mimics a really common but nasty accident that often leads to some bad injuries.

EVA
Yeah, the article described it as hitting a barrier at 40 mph with only 1/4 of the bumper making contact.

MAX
Ouch. Exactly. It’s meant to be like those glancing hits you see at intersections where one car just clips the front corner of another. The article said 1/4 of all the serious and deadly injuries from front end crashes happened this way. Makes this test pretty important for real world safety.

EVA
So it’s not just about head on collisions anymore.

MAX
Right. This new test is forcing car makers to think differently about design, especially reinforcing those front corners where it counts.

EVA
Speaking of design, this article tested 2 versions of the Ford F-150, the Super Crew and Super Cab, and the results were totally different. Same make, same model but wildly different comes the Super Crew, the bigger one that’s really popular aced it got a good rating.

MAX
That’s right, high as possible, the article said. It’s strong cab. The reinforced structure, all those extra supports, they work perfectly to absorb the impact, keeping the people inside safe.

EVA
That’s good to hear, especially if you’re thinking of getting a truck. But what about the Super Cab then?

MAX
This is where it gets interesting. The Super Cab got a marginal rating.

EVA
Marginal doesn’t sound terrible.

MAX
Well, it’s actually the second worst score you can get.

EVA
Oh wow, what?

MAX
Happened the article. People said the Super cabs cab basically crumpled during impact. Not good. They said. This kind of damage is really risky for people inside, especially compared to the Super crew which had almost no intrusion.

EVA
Crazy how a small difference in a rating can mean such a different outcome in a real crash. So we’ve got these two F1 fifties, same make and model but totally different crash test results. Makes you think, what does this mean for someone actually buying a truck, especially when it comes to insurance.

MAX
That’s the big question. This is about more than just a safety rating. Insurance companies, they’re all about risk and how a vehicle does in these tests. That plays a huge role.

EVA
Makes sense, The more likely a car is to be in a bad accident, the more the insurance company has to pay out.

MAX
Right, exactly in this article, it connects those crash test results right to your insurance premiums. Vehicles like that super cab with its marginal rating, statistically they lead to bigger insurance claims. And what happens then? Higher premiums for the owner.

EVA
Hold on, so if I’m picking between a new Super Crew and Super Cab, the Super crew could actually save me money on insurance?

MAX
That’s what the article saying. It’s a big change how we think about car safety. It’s not just some idea anymore, it’s tied right to our wallets.

EVA
Wow, never thought of it that way. A crash test actually saving you money. What about Ford though? They can’t be happy about the Super Cab getting flagged like this, especially if it hurts sales.

MAX
You’re right, this puts carmakers in a tough spot. The article does mention Ford’s response though. Pretty interesting how they’re reacting to all this safety stuff. They said the small overlap test was pretty new when they designed that all aluminum super cab.

EVA
So they’re saying they didn’t know about this kind of crash test when they designed it.

MAX
Not exactly, they said it was relatively new. Didn’t say they didn’t know. But car design? It takes years, tons of research. It’s possible that Super Cab was already finalized. You know, designs done before this specific test became a big deal.

EVA
Like trying to hit a moving target the way you were saying earlier. Safety standards always changing.

MAX
Right, But the good news is Ford’s working on it. The article says they’re improving the Super cabs design using what they learned from this crash test.

EVA
Good. At least they’re running up to it and doing something.

MAX
Yeah, shows they’re listening both to people buying the trucks and the insurance companies, too. And it proves these crash tests are making a difference. It’s not just passing some tests now, it’s about making cars that are actually safer.

EVA
OK, I get it, but it makes you wonder if insurance is already changing prices based on these tests.

MAX
Are we heading to a place where how you drive matters even more?

EVA
Exactly like what if our insurance was based on our actual driving, not just the car?

MAX
Think about it, what if they use data from your car’s computer, your speed, how you brake, even if you take corners smoothly?

EVA
That’s kind of cool, but kind of creepy too. Like it seems fair that safer drivers payless, but do we want insurance? Knowing that much about us feels risky.

MAX
Definitely both sides to that coin. It could make people drive better, which is good for everyone. But yeah, big questions about privacy, who has her information, all that that’s.

EVA
A whole other conversation. For now, though, let’s get back to the topic at hand.

MAX
Back to those crash tests and what they mean for our wallets right now.

EVA
So crash tests, they’re not just some safety rating, they actually affect what kind of cars get made A&D, how much we pay for insurance. But the big question how much do those ratings really hit our wallets?

MAX
That’s the $1,000,000 question, right? It depends, of course, on the insurance company, all those factors. But this article suggested a lower crash test rating, like that marginal one for the Super Cab, could mean paying a lot more for insurance. Like hundreds of dollars more every year.

EVA
Whoa, seriously makes those little differences in the ratings seem a lot bigger now?

MAX
Exactly, and This is why you got to be a smart shopper when you’re looking at a new car. Don’t just skim those crash test ratings. Really get what they mean. Make it part of your decision alongside gas mileage, all the features, the price, everything.

EVA
It’s like those crash tests are speaking a whole new language now. The language of money.

MAX
Right. And it’s not just new cars either. If you’ve got a car already, especially an older one, look up its crash test results. You might be surprised how it does on these new tests. They’re tougher now.

EVA
Good point. More. You know, right, If we understand our cars, how they’re built for safety, we can make smarter choices about our insurance, our safety on the road, all of.

MAX
It couldn’t have said it better myself.

EVA
There we have it. We did it. A deep dive into the world of crash testing, how this new test is changing the game for car companies, and of course, how it all comes back to our bank accounts. Who knew a simple test could be so impactful?

MAX
It’s all connected safety design, the Tekken cars now and yeah, even our own money. This just shows car safety is always evolving and his drivers got to keep up, make our voices heard.

EVA
Well said. And on that note, we’ll wrap up this deep dive. Until next time, everyone, stay curious, stay informed, and most importantly, stay safe out there on the road.

It turns out, not all Ford F-150s were created equal, and the insurance industry has some questions, concerns, and potential rate hikes because of it. When put to the test in a tough new crash test, one version of the truck met the challenge and held up remarkably. The other version? Not so much.

A Tougher Test

In recent years, auto experts and crash test designers have begun to conduct tests that are widely considered to be more stringent and rigorous than previous any previous trials. One such test that has been implemented in 2012 is the ‘small overlap front crash test’. While the name might sound innocuous, the test itself is brutal and can bring a vehicle to a screeching halt. The vehicle, traveling at 40 miles per hour, strikes a barrier with just one quarter of its front bumper. The impact is designed to occur on the driver side of the vehicle. The resulting crash can cause major destruction to a poorly designed car, and lead to significant injury or loss of life if it were to happen in the real world. According to the Insurance Institute, crashes that involve “small overlaps” such as those tested in the crash trials account for a quarter of all serious or fatal injuries in front impact accidents. In vehicles which lack the structural integrity or quality materials, the entire front cab of the vehicle and collapse under such an impact.

The Good News and the Bad News

Originally, the Insurance Institute had intended to test only the Ford F150 SuperCrew truck. The SuperCrew is widely considered the most popular version of the vehicle. In the small overlap front crash test, the all-aluminum Ford F150 SuperCrew performed well. The engineering of the cab as well as additional structural supports throughout the body of the vehicle created a safer crash experience and the SuperCrew was awarded a safety rating of “Good”, the Institute’s highest rating.

The SuperCab version of the Ford F150, however, was a different story all together. With a smaller passenger compartment and fewer of the structural supports present in the SuperCrew version of the vehicle, the results from the test crash were disconcerting. Upon impact, the entire cab of the SuperCab buckled and the body around the passengers collapsed entirely. The Insurance Institute awarded the vehicle with the safety rating of “Marginal”, the second to worst rating a vehicle could get.

Being Marginal Will Cost You

In addition to providing consumers with a more informed buying experience when purchasing a vehicle, the Insurance Industry has another reason for conducting these tests and showing concern for vehicles that do not pass the muster. While preventing serious injury and reducing fatal flaws in vehicles, the Insurance Industry conducts these tests to improve their bottom line. At the end of the day, their main concern is the Insurance Industry’s profitability, and vehicles that are more likely to result in serious injury or death can spell trouble for insurers.

Vehicles that have a higher occurrence of serious injury, death, or major repair are more likely to result in major claims and higher payouts. In other words: These vehicles cost the insurance companies money. What does this mean for the consumer? Generally, it means that vehicles such as the Ford F150 SuperCab could carry with them a premium on their insurance premiums. The riskier a vehicle is, the higher the insurance premium can be.

For its part, Ford has begun the process of redesigning and adjusting the marginal SuperCab. According to executives at Ford, the new small overlap front crash test was still too new when the all-aluminum truck had been created, and proper adjustments had not yet been implemented. Regardless, the Insurance Industry is watching and ready to pass the risk onto you.

video source:
CNNMoney (Jul 30, 2015) – “Watch the new aluminum Ford F-150’s crash test”